Dear Leaders

A weekly letter with actionable leadership ideas.

Decision Fatigue in Senior Leadership Roles

By Hamza Shayk

Dear Leaders,

You’re in the business of making decisions. Every decision you make impacts the entire organization. Granted, some decisions are more impactful than others, but, in your capacity, all of them carry significant weight.

In the words of Ted Lasso, “Given the good ol’ fact that you’re a human being that gets worn out as the day passes”, and to avoid any mishaps in decision-making in your capacity, it’s worth revisiting some of the basics of decision fatigue, the consequences of neglecting it, and how to keep it in check.

You probably experience it often and are likely well aware of the concept, so I’ll get the quick definition out of the way:

Decision fatigue is the decline in the quality of our decisions after an extended period of decision-making. Why? Because the more choices we make, the more our cognitive resources dwindle.

What decision-making risks are involved when senior leadership is fatigued?

1. Quality erosion. Decision fatigue leads to subpar choices. Your brain resorts to shortcuts, increasing the odds of impulsive and poorly thought-out decisions.

2. Risk avoidance. Fatigued leaders tend to retreat from calculated risks, clinging to the familiar and stifling innovation in the process.

3. Productivity decline. Decision fatigue isn’t just about bad choices; it affects your overall productivity. Tasks take longer, and mental clarity dissipates, hindering efficiency.

4. Willpower drain. The cognitive toll of constant decision-making depletes your willpower. This makes it harder to maintain self-control and stay aligned with strategic goals.

What are some strategies for senior leaders to reduce decision fatigue?

1. Unwavering prioritization. The core strategy lies in prioritization. Devote your mental energy to the most critical decisions. Rank tasks by importance and allocate your cognitive resources accordingly.

2. Structured decision-making. Implement decision-making frameworks that streamline choices. Set clear evaluation criteria or involve your trusted team for collective insights. Decisions don’t have to be solitary endeavors.

3. Automate the mundane. Automate routine decisions in your daily routines and workflows. Whether it’s email management or repetitive tasks, eliminate low-impact choices that drain your cognitive capacity.

Mark Zuckerberg, Steve Jobs, Barry Diller, and countless other CEOs go as far as wearing the same outfit every day to avoid spending any intellectual resources on selecting a new outfit every morning.

4. Strategic mindfulness. Take brief intermissions between demanding tasks. These moments of respite recharge your cognitive resources and act as buffers against decision fatigue.

How can senior leaders build resilience against decision fatigue?

Building resilience against decision fatigue isn’t a one-time effort; it’s a sustained discipline.

Here’s how:

1. Routine self-review. Regularly assess your decision-making processes. Are you consistently prioritizing, employing frameworks, and automating where possible? Continual refinement is key.

2. Delegation expertise. Hone your delegation skills. Delegate decisions when appropriate, trusting your team’s expertise. It’s a sign of strength, not weakness.

3. Mental well-being. Prioritize your mental well-being. Adequate sleep, a balanced diet, and regular exercise are non-negotiable for maintaining cognitive resilience.

4. Strategic retreats. Consider strategic retreats where you disconnect from the constant decision churn. These retreats provide the mental space needed for reflection and rejuvenation. Put simply, take vacations often.

In Conclusion

In senior leadership, mastering decision fatigue isn’t an option; it’s a necessity. Awareness of its presence and the associated risks is the first step. Through unwavering prioritization, structured decision-making, automation, and strategic breaks, you can build a fortress of resilience. Discipline is your sentry against its subtle erosion.

Just as a seasoned captain steers a ship through tumultuous waters, your organization relies on your unwavering resolve. Be the leader who navigates with clarity and purpose, for your decisions chart the course forward.

Stay vigilant in your choices as you forge the path to your organization’s future.

Wondering if we're a fit? Me too. Let's find out:


What the Best Managers Do Differently

Dear Leaders, Low employee engagement is a pressing concern that many of you have expressed in our conversations. How can we improve it? Recent Gallup studies provide some insight: – Only 33% of employees are fully engaged and thriving. – 51% are ‘quiet quitting’, meaning doing the bare minimum. – And the remaining 16% are… Continue reading What the Best Managers Do Differently

April 01, 2024

Why and How to be a Decisive Leader

Dear Leaders, Once again, the business landscape is ripe with opportunities for leaders bold enough to risk a false step on their quest for the right course. Embracing safety is now synonymous with embracing risk. You are tasked with navigating an increasingly complex world. While a cautious stance may seem prudent, don’t fall for it.… Continue reading Why and How to be a Decisive Leader

March 01, 2024

Feeling Threatened by your Subordinate’s Rapid Ascent? Stop It.

Dear Leaders, Fun fact: If you’re good at your job, your employer does not want to replace you. It’s just not in their best interest. Why? Because they need the job done well and it’s extremely difficult to find a good replacement. A fact that’s even more fun:  If you’re excellent at your job, you’ll… Continue reading Feeling Threatened by your Subordinate’s Rapid Ascent? Stop It.

February 01, 2024



Get Dear Leaders delivered weekly